Home > Punishments & Tactics > Experiencing Negative Consequences of a Decision

Experiencing Negative Consequences of a Decision

By: Beth Morrisey MLIS - Updated: 2 Feb 2013 | comments*Discuss
 
Children Bad Decisions Consequences

It is usually tempting to step in and save your child from making a mistake, but sometimes children need to learn on their own why taking a particular decision isn’t the best option. Allowing a child to take a bad decision and experience the negative consequences which result can be a powerful teaching tool. When you decide to let your child learn from experience be sure to pick an appropriate situation for the lesson, let your child experience all of the consequences, speak with him or her about what happened and support your child as (s)he works through the effects of the decision.

Picking An Appropriate Situation

Children tend to make decisions quickly, emotionally and without necessarily a great deal of research or forethought. This means that everyday there could be myriad situations in which you might deliberately allow your child to make a mistake. Only allow this in appropriate situations, such that:

  • No one will be physically or emotional hurt by the decision or consequences.
  • The incident will be quick and contained.
  • Your child will experience the consequences shortly after making the decision.
  • It will be clear that the consequences resulted from the decision.
  • The consequences will not add a great deal of stress to your life.
  • The decision will not effect anyone else’s property or personal items.
  • The consequences will not have much effect on anyone besides your child.

Experiencing All of the Consequences

Once a child begins to realise the negative consequences of a decision (s)he may become emotional. This could easily translate into physical effects such as tears, headaches or tummy aches. It can be tempting to let your child off the hook and try to fix the situation on your own. Don’t allow this. All you will be teaching your child is that you will be available to fix things so they can make any decision they like. Instead, help your child remain calm and remind him or her that you will be there to help them through the consequences.

Discussing the Decision

Discuss the decision your child made once the negative consequences become clear. Ask him or her:
  • Why did (s)he make the decision?
  • What did (s)he think the other options were?
  • What did (s)he think would happen?
  • What does (s)he see as the consequences now looming?
  • Does (s)he think these consequences are fair?
  • How can (s)he now best get through the consequences?
  • How can you help him or her through the consequences?
  • What could (s)he do differently next time?

Supporting Your Child Through the Effects

Reassure your child that you will be there to help him or her through the consequences (s)he now faces as a result of the bad decision. For example, if she decided not to do a school assignment and received a poor mark, offer to help her set up a study schedule and better prepare for future assessments. Or if he decided to stay up late reading after you told him to go to sleep, wake him up on time and require that he go through his normal schedule but offer to help him focus on homework early so that he can get to bed at a better time. Don’t allow your child to wriggle out of the consequences of a decision, but help him or her deal with them in the most positive way possible.

Experiencing a negative consequence of a decision is a powerful learning tool for a child. If possible pick an appropriate situation, allow your child to experience all of the consequences, discuss the decision and support your child through the effects so that (s)he will learn something from the experience.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • Miss Sunshine
    Re: Children and Pinching
    My brother is a pincher. He's 42. He pinches my 6 year old son if he doesn't follow rules. I told him to stop. He said it was nothing.
    21 April 2019
  • Ryerye
    Re: Children and Body Rocking
    I have the same problem me reading this helped much understand a lot more I am 12 and I hate the feel of paper and dry objects I still…
    5 April 2019
  • Divamum
    Re: Positive and Negative Reinforcement for Good Behaviour
    I think this article is unfounded and poorly written. Since when do parents have ‘job…
    4 April 2019
  • Ann
    Re: Oppositional Defiant Disorder (ODD)
    My son is 8years old he has always been different i had a emergancie section with hm i cat even sit with him he pnches me…
    4 April 2019
  • Marian
    Re: Children and Pinching
    I know a girl who pinches at 15 what can I do ? I was thinking cutting limbs off but I thought that was unethical.
    29 March 2019
  • Sookie
    Re: Children and Body Rocking
    I rocked a lot until I was 18 years old. It was so soothing. I rocked so hard my mother had to tell me to stop. I thought I had a…
    29 March 2019
  • Jacko
    Re: Children and Hitting
    My soon to be 7 year old son hits class mates been reading up on his behaviour an "symptoms" of his behaviour dont really count in his case…
    6 March 2019
  • ggbg
    Re: Smacking and Children
    guys stop putting silly comments my little son commited suicide
    5 March 2019
  • dr love
    Re: Smacking and Children
    Black screen with text; The sound of buzzing bees can be heard) According to all known laws of aviation, there is no way a…
    5 March 2019
  • planeflying69
    Re: Smacking and Children
    i kill kids on a daily and fly planes into towers
    4 March 2019