Home > Discipline & Respect > Discipline Versus Punishment

Discipline Versus Punishment

By: Beth Morrisey MLIS - Updated: 8 Nov 2012 | comments*Discuss
 
Discipline Punishment Disciplining

When children misbehave it can be very difficult to think of anything other than making them stop. For many children this means punishing a child, such as by taking away the item involved in misbehaviour, by telling a child that (s)he will not be able to attend a favourite activity later, or even by Smacking The Child. Many parents think that punishing a child will teach him or her discipline, but this is not the case. Punishment and discipline are two very distinct concepts and they should not be used interchangeably as they so often are.

Discipline and Children

Disciplining children helps them to realise what has gone wrong, that they have become out of control and that they need to regain control before an activity can continue. This is done in a positive and consistent manner so that children can see the pattern of what is appropriate behaviour and what is inappropriate behaviour. It is also done through a variety of positive options so that when children realise that they have acted inappropriately, they can select an alternate, more appropriate course of action for the future. Discipline does not seek to simply call out children’s faults or misgivings (which very often is the basis of punishment), and instead uses praise for appropriate behaviour to gain results.

Discipline is also never physical (while punishment very well may include swatting or smacking), sarcastic, belittling or disrespectful. Finally, discipline is a means of leading by example. Parents who want to teach their children best behaviour display this behaviour themselves rather than saying one thing and doing another. Unfortunately, punishment very commonly is the result when children copy something inappropriate that their parents have done, which is not fair to anyone.

Discipline Techniques

In order to teach children Self-Discipline, adults must act as regulators and supervisors for a time so that they can teach children what is appropriate and what is not. There are many methods of disciplining a child, and some may work particularly well for one child but not at all for another. This is normal. Most children do not respond well to all methods of discipline and so a wide range should be tested to find out which method suits which child.

Ignoring misbehaviour and encouraging positive alternatives, putting a child in open-ended time-out to allow him or her to regain their self-control, discussing inappropriate actions and how to make up for them, Using Sticker And Star Charts to map good behaviour, and giving a child two positive options for future actions are all methods of discipline that help redirect children to more appropriate behaviours. Delivering discipline in private, in a controlled voice or even a whisper and while an adult is kneeling down to look directly into a child’s eyes will likely make the episode more efficient for everyone involved.

It’s never fun when a child loses control or misbehaves, but such situations are a natural part of growing up and maturing. To help them along the way, parents should take care to discipline their children and help teach them self-control rather than punishing them and having no one at all learn from the situation.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • Anonymous
    Re: Smacking and Children
    @Rose and Jizzy - have you tried speaking with a teacher about it? If it is happening ALL the time so it's not 'reasonable punishment' then…
    19 February 2021
  • Livi
    Re: Children and Body Rocking
    My sister was a rocker and a head banger in to her teens and she is a total wacko nut job now 50 Just saying!
    18 February 2021
  • connork
    Re: Grounding Children
    i was grounding for 6 weeks for some pirvat stuf AND IM 8 so my dad went on a rv trip and dident take me i lost everything my xbox and he said…
    9 February 2021
  • a kid
    Re: Grounding Children
    i broke 1 minior rule so bacicly im on house arrest for 7 and a half years not lying
    4 February 2021
  • a kid
    Re: Grounding Children
    im 11 and im grounded untill im 18 years old
    4 February 2021
  • whale
    Re: Children and Self-Harm
    My 8 year old brother has been scratching himself for a while when i tell him its time to shower or when i tell him to do something he…
    24 January 2021
  • naz
    Re: Grounding Children
    i've been grounded for ten years because of fortnite
    21 January 2021
  • Jizzy
    Re: Smacking and Children
    So im 12 and my mom has hit me many times before. I suffer from depression and PTSD from it. Sometimes when she moves her hand slightly too…
    8 January 2021
  • Jizzy
    Re: Grounding Children
    So im 12 years and the reason im in trouble for is private but long story short, my mom went through my phone when me and my friends were…
    8 January 2021
  • Mom
    Re: Grounding Children
    I am a mother of four. Three teenagers and an eight year old. I know from personal experience spankings don't work! It just makes the kids act…
    27 December 2020